Carina Bay All-Inclusive Resort & Casino
Adults-only resort in Saint Croix.
Amenities
Traveler Insights(198 discussions)
Carina Bay All-Inclusive Resort & Casino occupies a genuinely unique position in the Caribbean: it's the only all-inclusive property on Saint Croix, which means it draws guests who are specifically seeking that format on an island most tourists skip in favor of St. Thomas or St. John. That underdog quality is part of what makes it interesting. Saint Croix is a real island with authentic Crucian culture, historical architecture in Christiansted, and diving at Buck Island National Monument that rivals anything in the USVI chain. Guests who treat this resort as a base for exploring that island consistently have the best time.
The resort's calling cards are its beachfront casino, its genuinely warm staff, and its adult-only adults-only atmosphere that keeps things calm and social without being rowdy. The casino with 200-plus slot machines and table games is a draw in itself, and the evening entertainment - DJ nights, live performances, and bar events - gives the property more energy than many quiet adult resorts. The staff, especially bartenders, are cited by name in review after review as the single best part of the experience. Downsides are real: sargassum seaweed is a documented recurring problem on this stretch of coast, dining quality gets mixed marks, and the property has faced criticism for inconsistent amenity availability.
Carina Bay fits best for travelers who prioritize a laid-back adults-only vibe, casino access, and genuine island exploration over pristine beach conditions or resort-size variety. It's meaningfully less expensive than St. Thomas options and offers something you cannot find anywhere else on Saint Croix. Go in knowing you'll want a rental car, that the beach might have seaweed days, and that the food is serviceable rather than memorable - and the staff warmth, nightlife energy, and unique island setting can absolutely deliver a memorable trip.
Pros
- +The only all-inclusive resort on Saint Croix, giving it a unique niche for travelers who want that format on an underrated USVI island
- +Beachfront location with a private beach, two freshwater pools, and direct access to snorkeling and kayaking
- +On-site casino with 200+ slot machines and Vegas-style table games - a genuine rarity in the Caribbean all-inclusive space
- +Exceptionally friendly and personable bartenders and staff who are consistently praised by name in traveler reviews
- +Adult-only property (18+) that keeps the atmosphere relaxed and free from the chaos of kid-heavy resorts
- +Lively evening programming including DJ nights, live music, and events that give the resort genuine energy after dark
- +Renovated rooms with clean bathrooms and ocean views at a resort that sits outside the typical tourist-heavy USVI circuit
- +Saint Croix itself is a significantly less-visited island than St. Thomas or St. John, giving the destination an uncrowded, authentic quality
Cons
- −Sargassum seaweed is a persistent and documented problem on this side of Saint Croix - the beach and water can be unusable during heavy influx periods, with a noticeable odor
- −Dining quality and variety receive mixed reviews - food is described by some guests as slightly below par for an all-inclusive at this price point
- −The resort's isolated location means you genuinely need a rental car to explore the island, eat off-property, or visit sites like Christiansted or Buck Island
- −Some amenities have historically been out of service or unavailable, including secondary bars, the gym, and watersports equipment during lower-traffic periods
- −Outdoor seating is a complaint for many guests - broken chairs, limited shade, and insufficient poolside furniture are mentioned repeatedly
- −The all-inclusive value proposition is questioned by some travelers who feel the food and drink quality doesn't justify the premium over booking a standard room rate
- −Saint Croix is harder to reach than more popular Caribbean islands - fewer direct flights, and connections through St. Thomas or San Juan add travel time
- −The boutique size (small room count) means the resort can feel limited in restaurant variety and pool space compared to larger all-inclusive competitors
Common Questions
Google Rating
Google Reviews
“Super nice and quiet... If you're looking for crazy drinks and 20oz steaks. This is not for you... If you're looking for quiet clean simple drinks and decent food with no waiting for anything, especially pool chairs. This is your spot. Will be retu...”
“We had an AMAZING time at the Carina Bay Boutique. When you pull up, it doesn't seem like much, but when you walk into the lobby... from the bar in the middle of the lobby to the deck and game room. This place is BEAUTIFUL!!! The staff was pleasant a...”