Guana Island
Family-friendly resort in Guana Island. Quiet, Family.
Things to Know
Atmosphere
Room Upgrades
Amenities
Traveler Insights(428 discussions)
Guana Island is one of those places that guests describe as difficult to explain to anyone who hasn't been. It's a private 850-acre island in the British Virgin Islands with a maximum of 35 guests, seven beaches, a full organic farm, and the kind of quiet that you can actually hear. There are no crowds because there are no crowds possible. The resort operates on a philosophy of subtraction: no nightlife, no spa, no casino, no over-programmed activity schedule - just an extraordinary natural environment with excellent food, generous beverage inclusion, and enough activities to fill every day if you want them.
The all-inclusive here is unusually comprehensive. All meals feature produce grown in the island's own orchard, prepared by a chef with serious fine-dining credentials. Wines and beverages beyond reserve bottles are fully included. Every day brings access to seven beaches, 12 miles of trails, snorkeling gear, kayaks, tennis, volleyball, and more. The snorkeling off Guana's northern tip - a Protected Fisheries Area - gets consistently called out as some of the best accessible reef snorkeling in the BVI. Hiking to Sugarloaf Mountain's summit takes guests past ruins of a Quaker sugar plantation and rewards the climb with panoramic views across the island chain.
Guana Island is for a very specific traveler: couples, small groups, or families (it can be booked in full for private buyouts) who want complete immersion in a pristine natural environment and don't need a resort to entertain them. The price places it firmly in the ultra-luxury tier, above most Caribbean all-inclusives and comparable to COMO Parrot Cay or Necker Island for the private-island experience. If you've done the bigger luxury chains and want something genuinely different - where the conversation at dinner is with strangers who become friends because you're all on a private island together - Guana delivers something most resorts simply cannot replicate.
Pros
- +Genuine private island experience with at most 30-35 guests at any time - many stays have closer to 15-20 people on the entire island
- +850-acre island with 12 miles of hiking trails, seven beaches, and a 806-foot summit at Sugarloaf Mountain that rewards climbers with commanding BVI views
- +Farm-to-table dining from the island's own organic orchard - the chef grows most vegetables, fruits, and herbs on property, which guests call out specifically as exceptional
- +All beverages including wines are included in the rate - this is notably more generous than many luxury all-inclusives that charge for premium alcohol
- +White Bay Beach is considered by many guests to be among the finest beaches in all of the British Virgin Islands, with outstanding snorkeling in the protected fisheries area just offshore
- +Snorkeling gear available anytime without booking or fees, with multiple sites including Muskmelon Bay and White Bay's coral gardens - and genuinely world-class reef health
- +On-island tennis courts, volleyball, croquet, ping-pong, bocce, horseshoes, kayaking, and wakeboarding included - activities span land and water for the full week
- +The intimacy creates genuine friendships between guests - travelers report that being one of a small handful of guests makes for a social dynamic unlike anything at a large resort
Cons
- −Wi-Fi is available but paid - connectivity is limited and intentionally minimal, which some guests love and others find frustrating for longer stays
- −No nightlife, no spa, no casino - this is explicitly an anti-resort and guests who expect entertainment programming or beauty services will be disappointed
- −The price point is among the highest in the Caribbean for all-inclusives, which puts it out of reach for most travelers and limits it to a narrow demographic
- −Access requires a boat or floatplane transfer from Tortola - the logistics require planning and can be disrupted by weather
- −No multiple restaurant options - dining is at one communal table for dinner, which some guests love for the social dynamic but others find limiting
- −The BVI had significant hurricane damage from Irma in 2017 and recovery took years - while the island has rebuilt, some infrastructure shows the history
- −Booking the entire island (buyout) is popular, which means entire weeks can be unavailable to individual room bookings on short notice
- −The understated room design - deliberately simple and nature-forward - can feel rustic compared to what the price tag implies for travelers expecting traditional luxury finishes
Common Questions
Google Rating
Google Reviews
“Guana Island is one of those niche little hideaway places that has been an open secret for years. It may not suit everyone's tastes. It could even be challenging, with its walkways and stairs that lead to some rooms. But this is made up for with its...”
“Stayed 5 days in Feb 2022. What an amazing experience! THE place for ultimate relaxation. Food was great. Buffet breakfast every morning with options of the daily special or custom standards, plus toast/bagels/croissants/yogurt/cereal. Lunch als...”
“Stayed here some years ago, what a great Island. Very secluded Amazing beach and sea life. The hotel was nice and the staff very helpful.”