Family-friendly resort in Andros. Family, Mid-Range.
Things to Know
Atmosphere
Room Upgrades
Amenities
Traveler Insights(410 discussions)
Small Hope Bay Lodge is one of those places that generates either deep devotion or quiet puzzlement, and which camp you fall into depends almost entirely on whether you are there for the water. For divers, this place has no real competitor in the Bahamas. The Andros Barrier Reef - the third-largest in the world - is virtually undived compared to Cozumel or Belize, and the wall dives at the edge of the continental shelf are frequently described by experienced divers as among the most memorable of their lives. Blue holes, shark dives, and pristine coral gardens are all within a short boat ride. The bonefish flats are equally celebrated among fly fishers, with guides who know every channel and flat by heart. This is the reason to come here, and if that reason resonates, everything else about the lodge falls into place.
The lodge itself is deliberately and authentically rustic. The 21 cabins are beachfront with porches facing the water, furnished simply with platform beds and local Androsia Batik fabric in the curtains, pillowcases, and wall hangings - the batik is made on Andros and its presence throughout the lodge feels earned rather than decorative. There are no TVs, no wifi in the rooms, and no pool. The conch fritter happy hour and communal dinner table create a genuine social atmosphere that regulars describe as the other reason they keep returning - the community of fellow divers and fishers who gather here year after year. All meals, all drinks, and all non-motorized water sports are included in the rate.
Small Hope Bay Lodge makes sense for experienced divers, fly fishers, snorkelers, and travelers who actively want to disconnect from screens and luxury amenities in favor of something more authentic. It does not make sense for couples wanting spa treatments and elegant restaurants, or for anyone who will be frustrated by rustic accommodations. Price-wise it sits at a mid-luxury all-inclusive level but the value calculus is entirely based on the diving and fishing access. Compared to Stuart Cove's in Nassau, the diving is less structured but far more pristine. Getting here is half the adventure - a small plane from Nassau to Andros takes about 20 minutes.
Pros
- +Access to the third-largest barrier reef in the world with 60+ dive sites including legendary wall dives at the edge of the continental shelf, blue holes, and shark observation dives
- +Bonefishing on the flats surrounding Andros Island is world-class - guides are consistently rated among the best in the Bahamas and the fishery sees far less pressure than Nassau or the Abacos
- +All-inclusive rate covers all meals, all drinks, kayaking, paddleboarding, sailing, snorkeling, and the nightly conch fritter happy hour - no nickel-and-diming
- +Genuinely unplugged experience - no TVs or wifi in cabins means guests are forced to actually disconnect, which regulars describe as the entire point
- +The Androsia Batik fabric used throughout the property gives the lodge a distinct, authentic identity directly connected to the local community that produces it
- +Small enough (21 cabins) that the communal table dinner creates a real social atmosphere - travelers meet, bonds form, and the staff know every guest by day one
- +Eco-friendly and family-run for over 60 years with deep roots in the Andros community - staying here directly supports local fishing families and guides
- +True off-the-beaten-path Bahamian experience on Andros, the largest and least-touristed island in the Bahamas, far from the Nassau cruise ship scene
Cons
- −Cabins are rustic and showing their age - platform beds, basic furnishings, and dated decor that feels worn rather than charming to some guests who expect luxury for the price
- −Air conditioning costs per night extra, which stings for travelers who assumed it would be included in an all-inclusive rate in the Caribbean heat
- −No wifi or TV in the cabins is a deliberate policy and a genuine dealbreaker for anyone who cannot fully disconnect or needs to work during the trip
- −Getting to Andros requires a small prop plane flight from Nassau or a ferry, adding meaningful time, cost, and logistical complexity compared to flying directly to Nassau
- −Limited cell phone signal throughout much of Andros, so staying connected with family or work is genuinely difficult
- −The dive operation has received a small number of scathing reviews from travelers who felt safety protocols and guide quality were inconsistent - not a universal complaint but worth researching recent reviews before booking
- −The remote location means there is almost nothing else to do off the lodge grounds - if diving, fishing, and beach activities are not your thing, there is very little to occupy you
- −Limited dining variety by design - the communal table concept means everyone eats what is being served that night, which some guests love and others find restrictive
Common Questions
Google Rating
Google Reviews
“Protect this place at all costs. This is the most special place we have ever stayed at and the service was exceptional beyond any 5-star resort we’ve been to. The staff anticipates your needs before you even have them and genuinely cares about you as...”
“Truly wonderful place. I chose to stay here because they provide tours to the West Side National Park, but there's so much more. It felt like a summer camp, where you have fun all day, and then chat with new friends during social gathering at the din...”
“I spent 5 days at Small Hope with a group of friends. This was a bit of a pricey investment for all of us. But I can say with absolute certainty that it was worth every penny. The staff is incredible. They were present and engaged and seemed to genui...”