Secrets St. Lucia Resort & Spa
Adults-only resort in Saint Lucia.
Room Upgrades
Amenities
Traveler Insights(312 discussions)
Secrets St. Lucia Resort & Spa represents one of the most dramatic resort reinventions in recent Caribbean history — a full-scale renovation of the former St. James's Club Morgan Bay, reopened in 2025 with the full Secrets luxury all-inclusive treatment. Set on Choc Bay with views toward Saint Lucia's volcanic peaks, the property brings a distinctly elevated vibe to an island that has historically been underserved by large all-inclusive brands. The 355-room resort spans hilly terrain with 9 restaurants, 6 lounges, multiple pool areas, and a spa, and its adults-only format creates a sophisticated atmosphere that appeals strongly to couples and honeymooners.
The dining program is a genuine strength — 14 food and beverage venues including a standout Italian restaurant (Portofino) and a crepes and tapas bar that guests repeatedly single out as highlights. Unlimited premium spirits are served poolside and beachside, and the Preferred Club tier unlocks quieter spaces and upgraded service for guests willing to pay the premium. Evenings come alive with fire shows, silent discos, and live entertainment, and the walk-in dining policy at all restaurants removes the advance-booking friction that can make some all-inclusives feel overly regimented. The small beach and hilly layout with no elevators are the most consistent practical complaints, alongside some service inconsistencies typical of a resort still finding its operational footing.
Secrets St. Lucia is best for adults who want the prestige of a dramatic Caribbean island setting combined with the polish of a major all-inclusive brand. It will appeal most to couples who have been to Secrets or AMResorts properties in Mexico or the Dominican Republic and want to experience that same formula in a more exotic, visually stunning location. Budget-conscious travelers should note that Saint Lucia airfare is higher than alternatives, and the Preferred Club upgrade is recommended to get the full experience. Those with mobility limitations should research room locations carefully given the significant hills and stair-heavy layout.
Pros
- +Massive variety of dining — 9 restaurants and 6 lounges cover everything from Italian to a crepes and tapas bar, so food fatigue is rarely an issue over a week-long stay
- +Unlimited premium spirits poured poolside and beachside without ever leaving your lounger, with a dedicated wait staff that keeps drinks flowing without you needing to flag anyone down
- +Preferred Club tier unlocks a quieter, more exclusive pool area, upgraded minibar, and a private breakfast setting — a meaningful step-up that justifies the price difference for couples who want more seclusion
- +Spectacular Saint Lucia setting on Choc Bay with the volcanic Piton mountains visible in the distance, offering one of the most visually dramatic backdrops of any Secrets property in the Caribbean
- +Lively entertainment program most nights — fire shows, DJ sets, live bands, and themed events like NFL watch parties and silent discos keep the evenings engaging for guests who want more than a quiet dinner
- +Beautifully renovated rooms with strong decor, comfortable beds, and excellent air conditioning — the 2024-2025 reopening brought a genuinely fresh finish to what was previously St. James's Club Morgan Bay
- +Adults-only policy throughout keeps the atmosphere sophisticated and the pool deck peaceful, drawing a mix of couples on honeymoon, anniversary trips, and solo escapes looking for a relaxed Caribbean vibe
- +Walk-in dining available at all restaurants without advance reservations, which removes the scheduling stress that plagues other Secrets properties and lets guests eat on their own timeline
Cons
- −The beach is small by Saint Lucia standards — guests seeking long stretches of sand for walking or beach sports will find the footprint limiting compared to larger Barbados or Punta Cana properties
- −No elevators in any of the resort buildings, and the property sits across hilly terrain with a lot of stairs — a real limitation for guests with mobility issues or those moving between far-flung sections of the resort
- −Buffet quality received mixed marks, particularly at breakfast in the early days of the resort's 2025 opening — specialty restaurants are consistently praised but the main buffet lags behind
- −Check-in delays have been widely reported, with rooms sometimes not ready until late afternoon and limited air-conditioned indoor space to wait comfortably in the Caribbean heat
- −The resort only opened (or more precisely, re-opened after renovation) in mid-2025, meaning some service and operational processes are still being refined — a first-year shakeout that more mature Secrets properties don't have
- −Saint Lucia is generally a more expensive destination to reach than other all-inclusive hubs like Cancun or Punta Cana, and flight options from many US cities require connections, adding travel complexity
- −Some guests note that the surrounding Choc Bay area outside the resort is less developed than other luxury resort corridors in the Caribbean, making off-resort excursions require more planning
- −Certain room categories are significantly uphill from the beach and main pool areas, which means guests not in premium categories may face a longer and steeper walk to the water multiple times a day
Common Questions
Google Rating
Google Reviews
“Secrets St. Lucia Resort and Spa was absolutely amazing from start to finish. The resort itself is incredibly clean and stunningly beautiful, with breathtaking views and well-maintained grounds that make it feel like a true paradise. The staff truly...”
“What a wonderful place! Beautiful beach, clean resort, food was excellent. We just returned after a week and have nothing but good things to say. Janeen at the Amstar tour desk on the resort set us up with a private car and driver and took A-1 care o...”
“We came here for our honeymoon and we are SO glad we did! We had the best time here. The staff was extremely friendly. The property was clean and just quiet enough to where we felt like there was always something to do but we could relax if we wanted...”